I Worked From Home During COVID. Can My Employer Make Me Come Back?

You did your job from home for two, three, maybe four years. Your reviews were fine. Now your employer says the job requires you in the office, and you want to know whether that track record counts for anything under the Americans with Disabilities Act.
It counts, but less than most people assume. Two federal appeals courts addressed this exact question in 2026 and came out in different places, for reasons that tell you what actually decides these cases. This guide covers what they held, how to read them together, and what makes a remote or hybrid accommodation request hold up now.
This is not legal advice, and nothing here guarantees an outcome. Your employer decides through the interactive process.
Key takeaways
Working remotely during COVID does not, by itself, make remote work a required accommodation. The Fifth Circuit said so directly in May 2026.
It is still evidence. In August 2026, the Third Circuit said whether in-person work was essential for a professor with a long remote-teaching history was a question for a jury.
Whether in-person attendance is an essential function is decided job by job, on the facts.
An employer that offers a partial remote schedule may satisfy its obligation even if you asked for full-time remote work.
The strongest request ties a documented functional limitation to a specific accommodation. Your pandemic track record supports it; it does not replace it.
What did the courts decide in 2026?
Hayes v. GStek, Inc. (Fifth Circuit, May 8, 2026). Albert Hayes was an IT systems administrator for an Army contractor at Fort Polk, Louisiana. He teleworked temporarily during the pandemic, returned to on-site work in 2022, and later submitted a physician's note asking to telework full time. The Army, which controlled telework for contractor staff, said full-time telework was not in its interest, so GStek allowed him to work from home two to three days a week instead. He was later fired and sued.
The Fifth Circuit affirmed judgment for the employer (opinion). It held that in-person attendance was an essential function of his job, relying on the Army's determination, the fact that similar contractor employees did not telework, and the employer's judgment. It said temporary pandemic telework did not change the job's essential functions, and wrote that in-person work "is presumed to be an essential function of most jobs." It also held the two-to-three-day arrangement satisfied the employer's duty, because an employer does not have to provide the employee's preferred accommodation. Foley & Lardner's summary is a good plain-language read.
Gardner v. Kutztown University (Third Circuit, August 18, 2026). A tenured associate professor at a public university asked to keep teaching remotely because of a medical condition. The university said in-person teaching was essential and refused. The district court had ruled for the professor outright.
The Third Circuit sent most of the case back for a jury (opinion). It held that whether in-person teaching and office hours were essential functions was a factual question, pointing to evidence that the professor had taught remotely for years before the pandemic and that her union contract did not require in-person work. Whether the university engaged in the interactive process in good faith for three semesters was also left to a jury. But for one later semester, the court sided with the university: its offers of a reconfigured classroom and plexiglass barriers were reasonable, and again, the employer did not have to provide the preferred accommodation. Ogletree Deakins' analysis covers the details.
Two technical points that matter. Hayes is a published opinion, binding on federal courts in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Gardner is marked non-precedential, so it does not bind any court, and it was decided under the Rehabilitation Act, which applies the same core employment standards as the ADA.
How to read the two cases together
They are less opposed than the headlines suggest. Both courts agree on three things:
The job's essential functions decide the case, not the company policy and not the pandemic.
Pandemic remote work is evidence, not proof. In Hayes, it could not outweigh an Army client's documented on-site requirement. In Gardner, a pre-pandemic remote teaching history plus a contract that did not require in-person work was enough to put the question in front of a jury.
An effective alternative can end the analysis. In both cases, the employer that offered a real alternative won at least that part of the dispute.
The practical conclusion: your employer cannot win just by pointing at its return-to-office policy, and you cannot win just by pointing at 2020 through 2023. The facts of your specific job decide it.
Is in-person attendance an "essential function" of my job?
EEOC regulations (29 C.F.R. 1630.2(n)(3)) list the kinds of evidence courts weigh when deciding whether a function is essential:
The employer's judgment about which functions are essential
Written job descriptions prepared before the job was advertised or filled
How much time is spent performing the function
The consequences of not requiring the person to perform it
The terms of a collective bargaining agreement
The work experience of past employees in the job
The current experience of employees in similar jobs
Notice how much of that list favors the employer by default, which is why the Fifth Circuit could talk about a presumption. It also shows where your pandemic history fits: "work experience of past employees" and "current experience of employees in similar jobs" can include how the job was actually done remotely, and for how long, with what results.
Jobs where presence is hard to argue away include roles that depend on on-site equipment, hands-on supervision, secure facilities, or a client's on-site requirement, as in Hayes. Jobs where it is easier to contest include roles that were remote or hybrid before 2020, roles your employer has continued to fill remotely elsewhere, and roles where the in-person requirement appears only in a new policy memo rather than in the job description.
Why "I did it during COVID" is not the argument
Courts treat pandemic arrangements as emergency responses, not permanent concessions. More importantly, an ADA accommodation is about a disability-related limitation, not a preference for a working arrangement. The EEOC and OPM's February 2026 telework FAQ makes two related points worth knowing. A long or difficult commute alone generally does not qualify someone for telework. And symptoms such as anxiety do not automatically qualify someone for telework unless they create a material barrier to performing the job.
That is the bar your documentation has to clear: what your condition prevents you from doing in the office, how that affects specific duties, and why the accommodation you are requesting addresses it. A note that says "the patient worked remotely successfully during COVID and should continue" does not clear it. For the full standard, see what an ADA mental health accommodation letter should include and do you need a diagnosis to get an ADA accommodation?
What makes a request stronger after Hayes and Gardner
Get your job description, and ask HR in writing which duties it considers essential and why they require presence.
Gather your remote performance record: reviews, metrics, and any assignments you completed remotely. Use it as supporting evidence, not as the core of the request.
Get documentation from a qualified provider that describes your functional limitations and connects them to the specific accommodation. The EEOC's psychiatric disabilities guidance explains how these conditions are evaluated.
Ask for what fits the job. If some on-site duties are real, a hybrid schedule, set in-office days, or a modified schedule is more realistic than full remote work. In Hayes, two to three days at home was enough. See ADA accommodation for hybrid work and modified and reduced work schedules under the ADA.
Engage with alternatives in good faith. If your employer offers an in-office accommodation, try it and document the results. Gardner shows that refusing every alternative can cost you that part of the case.
Keep it in writing. Requests, responses, offers, and outcomes.
If your condition is anxiety-related, reasonable accommodations for anxiety at work lists options beyond remote work. For the request itself, see how to request a remote work accommodation under the ADA.
Where you work changes how this plays out
Federal appeals courts are organized by region, and each circuit's published decisions bind the federal courts within it.
Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi): Hayes is binding. Expect courts to start from the in-person presumption. See ADA workplace accommodation evaluations in Texas.
Third Circuit (Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware): Gardner is not binding, but it shows how this circuit's judges approach essential-function disputes. See our pages for Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
Everywhere else: courts look at the same factors, and some state disability laws are broader than the ADA. An employment attorney in your state can tell you how local courts handle these cases.
If your employer says no
A denial is often the start of the interactive process rather than the end. Ask for the reason in writing, address any gaps your employer identifies, and propose a specific alternative. The step-by-step version is in your ADA accommodation request was denied: a step-by-step action plan, and the limits on lawful denials are in can my employer deny my ADA accommodation request? For more on the rights you keep after a denial, see your employer denied your remote work request: here are your rights under the ADA. The deadline to file an EEOC charge is generally 180 days, extended to 300 days in many states.
How WorkWell handles this
WorkWell connects you with a PSYPACT-authorized licensed psychologist via telehealth, from a group of independent providers we partner with. The provider you meet with makes all clinical decisions independently, including whether to issue a letter.
Prescreen and intake (about 15 minutes): you confirm eligibility, then complete a clinical intake covering your symptoms and how they affect your work.
Video consultation (15 minutes): the provider confirms your intake, assesses your functional limitations, and decides whether documentation is clinically appropriate.
Letter: if appropriate, it is typically delivered within 3 business days and written to the EEOC sufficiency standard, tied to your current duties.
A Standard Evaluation is $169. Complete Support is $299 and adds up to 3 employer form completions and up to 2 provider follow-ups within a 90-day window, which helps when HR comes back with questions about essential functions. What counts for eligibility is where you physically are during the call: it must be a PSYPACT jurisdiction.
We do not guarantee your employer will approve remote work. We make sure your documentation answers the question courts are actually asking.
Ready to start? Check your eligibility. It takes 2 minutes.
Sources and further reading
Gardner v. Kutztown University, No. 25-1295 (3d Cir. Aug. 18, 2026)
EEOC: Enforcement Guidance on Reasonable Accommodation and Undue Hardship under the ADA
Foley & Lardner: Full-Time Remote Work Is Rarely Reasonable Accommodation
Frequently asked questions
If I worked remotely during COVID, does my employer have to let me keep doing it? No. The Fifth Circuit held in 2026 that pandemic telework did not change a job's essential functions. Your employer must still consider an individual accommodation request.
Can my past remote work help my accommodation request? Yes, as evidence. In Gardner, a long remote-teaching history helped make essential function a question for a jury. It supports your request but does not replace documentation of your limitations.
Is full-time remote work ever a reasonable accommodation? Yes, in some cases, especially where it is the only effective accommodation. Where several options work, your employer may choose.
My employer offered hybrid but I asked for full remote. Do I have to accept? Your employer must provide an effective accommodation, not your preferred one. If hybrid does not address your limitations, your documentation should explain exactly why.
Do these rulings apply in my state? Hayes binds federal courts in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Gardner binds no court but may persuade. State laws can add protections.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Case summaries are simplified; read the opinions for full detail. Accommodation decisions remain with your employer through the interactive process. Consult a licensed attorney for advice specific to your situation.
Written by the WorkWell Evals team. WorkWell connects employees with PSYPACT-licensed psychologists for ADA workplace accommodation evaluations. Available in 40+ states via telehealth. Learn more at workwellevals.com.