Your Employer Wants You to Resubmit Your Remote Work Accommodation: What to Do

A woman's hands filling out a printed accommodation reevaluation form at a white quartz kitchen island, with a laptop, an older paper-clipped letter, and a mug of tea, rain on the window behind

If your employer has asked you to resubmit, recertify, or "re-request" a remote work accommodation you already have, it is not automatically a denial. Return-to-office policies are tightening again, and many employers are using each new policy as the moment to look at every existing arrangement a second time.

The latest example is Xbox. Starting February 1, 2027, Xbox employees in the Puget Sound area who live within 50 commuting miles of Studio D must work from the office at least four days a week, up from Microsoft's three-day baseline (Pure Xbox). Employees with existing exemptions will have to resubmit them (NewsBytes). The reporting does not say whether those exemptions include disability accommodations, but the question every affected employee faces is the same one this guide answers: what can your employer lawfully ask for, and what should you send back?

This guide is not legal advice, and it does not promise your employer will keep your accommodation in place. Your employer makes that decision through the interactive process.

Key takeaways

  • An employer can reevaluate an existing accommodation when circumstances change, including a new office policy. A reevaluation is not a denial.

  • A new policy alone is not a lawful reason to revoke every accommodation at once. Each one still needs an individualized assessment.

  • Your employer can ask for updated documentation, but only what is needed to establish the disability and the need for the accommodation. It cannot demand your full medical records.

  • Your employer may offer an effective in-office alternative instead of remote work. Your updated documentation should say whether that alternative would work, and why.

  • Respond in writing, on time, with documentation that matches the job you do today.

Is a resubmission request the same as a denial?

No, and the distinction matters for how you respond.

A policy "exemption" and an ADA accommodation are two different things. An exemption is a business decision your employer made under its own attendance rules, often approved by a manager with no medical documentation behind it. An ADA accommodation is the result of a legal process: you requested a change because of a disability, your employer evaluated it, and the two of you settled on an arrangement through the interactive process.

If your arrangement was granted as a disability accommodation, treat the resubmission as the interactive process reopening, not closing. If it was a general policy exception, the new policy may simply end it, and if you have a qualifying condition you would need to make a formal accommodation request for the first time. If you are not sure which one you have, ask HR in writing. Their answer tells you which process you are in.

Can my employer make me reapply for an accommodation I already have?

Generally yes, within limits.

The clearest current statement comes from the EEOC and OPM's February 2026 telework FAQ. It says existing telework accommodations can be reassessed periodically and after material changes such as a return-to-office directive, but should not be revoked without an individualized assessment of each employee. That document was written for federal agencies under the Rehabilitation Act and is technical assistance, not binding law. It is still the best signal available of how the EEOC views the same question for private employers under the ADA. Our breakdown of what the 2026 telework guidance means for your request covers it in more depth.

The enforcement side is real. In April 2026, FedEx agreed to pay $280,000 to resolve an EEOC lawsuit alleging it denied disabled dispatchers' requests to keep working from home, citing an operational need to have every dispatcher in its Manhattan office, and failed to engage with them on alternatives. The lesson for employers is that a policy is not a substitute for an individualized review. The lesson for you is that a reevaluation done properly is lawful, and one done as a rubber stamp is not.

There is also no fixed expiration date on accommodation documentation under the ADA. What triggers a legitimate update request is a change: in your condition, your duties, or the employer's operations. We cover that in do ADA accommodation letters expire?

What can my employer ask for this time?

When a disability or the need for accommodation is not obvious, an employer may request documentation, but under the EEOC's reasonable accommodation guidance that request is limited to what is needed to establish the disability and the need for the accommodation. It cannot demand your complete medical records. The 2026 FAQ adds that information requests must have a reasonable purpose and use reasonable means, and that unreasonably broad or invasive requests may unlawfully interfere with your accommodation rights.

In practice, your employer can:

  • Ask for updated documentation if the original record was insufficient or no longer reflects your situation

  • Ask you to sign a limited release so it can send specific questions to your provider

  • In limited cases, if the information you provide stays insufficient after you have had a chance to supplement it, require an examination by a provider of its choosing at its own expense

It cannot demand your full chart, your therapy notes, or your treatment history as a condition of reviewing your request. If you are worried about what HR will see, read can your employer ask your diagnosis?

A useful first step: if your condition and your role have not changed and your existing documentation is recent and complete, say so in writing and ask HR exactly what they consider missing. A specific answer is much easier to address than a general "please resubmit."

What should updated documentation cover?

Under EEOC guidance, documentation is sufficient when it describes the nature, severity, and duration of the impairment, the activities it limits, and the extent of those limits, and substantiates why the requested accommodation is needed. For a reevaluation, a strong letter covers:

  1. The provider's credentials and how they assessed you

  2. Your current condition: its nature, severity, and expected duration. If it is episodic, it can still qualify if it would substantially limit a major life activity when active.

  3. Current functional limitations, tied to the duties you perform now, not the job you had when the original letter was written

  4. Why the accommodation is needed, including why any in-office alternative your employer has proposed would or would not address those limitations

  5. Whether a partial arrangement would work, such as a hybrid schedule or set in-office days

  6. A review point, so the next reevaluation has a natural date

Two accuracy points. A formal written diagnosis is not the legal test for sufficiency, but the condition still has to be a clinically recognized disorder assessed by a qualified provider, not general stress about the policy. And the assessment is made without regard to the benefit of medication or therapy, so "it is well managed" does not mean you no longer qualify. More detail is in what an ADA mental health accommodation letter should include.

What if my employer offers an in-office alternative instead?

An employer must provide an effective accommodation, not necessarily your preferred one. If two options are both effective, the employer may choose. The 2026 FAQ lists examples of in-office alternatives: modified equipment, changes to sound, light, or smell in the workspace, job restructuring, flexible scheduling, and reduced telework combined with in-office measures.

The FAQ also says an employer may ask you to try an in-office accommodation first. If the trial shows it does not work, the employer should consider further changes and may return to telework. Take a trial seriously and document what happens: which tasks were affected, how often, and how. That record is what your provider and your employer will rely on next.

Middle-ground options are often the most realistic outcome. See ADA accommodation for hybrid work and ADA schedule accommodations.

What happens if I don't respond?

The interactive process runs both ways. You carry the initial burden of requesting an accommodation, and if you ignore a reasonable request for updated information, your employer may be able to close the review on what it already has. Practical rules:

  • Respond in writing before the deadline. If you need more time to get documentation, ask for an extension in writing and say when you expect to have it.

  • Keep copies of everything you send and receive.

  • Once a decision has been made through a proper process, simply not complying can expose you to discipline. If you disagree, use the reconsideration or appeal route.

If HR goes quiet after you submit, see what to do if your employer doesn't respond.

A timeline that works for a February deadline

Work backward from the effective date of the new policy:

  1. This week: ask HR in writing whether your arrangement is an accommodation or a policy exception, what they need from you, and by when.

  2. Within two weeks: get your documentation updated. For timing benchmarks, see how long it takes to get an ADA accommodation letter.

  3. Four to six weeks before the effective date: submit, so there is room for HR's follow-up questions and a trial of any alternative.

  4. After submitting: know what comes next. What happens after your employer receives your letter walks through it.

If your employer rescinds the accommodation anyway

Ask for the reason in writing, supplement your documentation if they say it was insufficient, and propose a specific alternative if full remote work was the sticking point. Requesting or using an accommodation is protected activity, and retaliating against you for it is prohibited. The full playbook is in your ADA accommodation request was denied: a step-by-step action plan, and the limits on lawful denials are in can my employer deny my ADA accommodation request? Private-sector employees generally have 180 days to file an EEOC charge, extended to 300 days in states with their own enforcement agency. Talk to a licensed employment attorney about your specific situation.

How WorkWell handles this

WorkWell connects you with a PSYPACT-authorized licensed psychologist via telehealth, from a group of independent providers we partner with. The provider you meet with makes all clinical decisions independently, including whether to issue an updated letter.

  • Returning WorkWell clients: a Standard Reevaluation is $149, and a Complete Support Reevaluation is $269, which adds up to 3 employer form completions and up to 2 provider follow-ups within a 90-day window. You upload your prior WorkWell documentation, complete an updated intake, and meet with a provider for a 15-minute video consultation. Start a reevaluation.

  • New to WorkWell: a Standard Evaluation is $169, and Complete Support is $299. Check your eligibility.

  • Turnaround: if your provider determines a letter is clinically appropriate, it is typically delivered within 3 business days of your consultation.

  • Location: what counts is where you physically are during the video call, not where you live or where your employer is based. That location has to be a PSYPACT jurisdiction. See the states page.

We do not guarantee your employer will keep your accommodation in place. We make sure the documentation you send back is current, specific, and built to the standard the EEOC describes.

Ready to start? Check your eligibility. It takes 2 minutes.

Sources and further reading

Frequently asked questions

Does an ADA accommodation letter expire? The ADA does not set an expiration date. Your employer can ask for updated information when something changes, such as your condition, your duties, or its office policy, but only what is needed to establish the disability and the need.

Can my employer revoke my remote work accommodation because of a new RTO policy? Not as a blanket rule. Each accommodation should get an individualized assessment. Your employer may replace remote work with an effective in-office alternative.

Do I need a new evaluation, or can I resend my old letter? If your letter is recent, describes your current limitations, and still matches your duties, resending it with a cover note may be enough. If anything has changed, or HR names specific gaps, updated documentation is usually needed.

Can my employer ask for my diagnosis? It can ask for information sufficient to establish disability and need, not your full records. A formal written diagnosis is not the legal standard, but the condition must be clinically recognized and assessed by a qualified provider.

Does a reevaluation guarantee I keep remote work? No. Your employer decides through the interactive process and may choose any effective accommodation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. WorkWell Evals is not affiliated with Microsoft or Xbox. Accommodation decisions remain with your employer through the interactive process. Consult a licensed attorney for advice specific to your situation.

Written by the WorkWell Evals team. WorkWell connects employees with PSYPACT-licensed psychologists for ADA workplace accommodation evaluations. Available in 40+ states via telehealth. Learn more at workwellevals.com.